Monticello, NM

The town was renamed in 1881 by its first postmaster, John Sullivan, of Monticello, N.Y.

Located along New Mexico Highway 142, Monticello was originally named Canada Alamosa Spanish for "Canyon of the Cottonwoods" and was first settled by ranchers and farmers in 1856. The town was renamed in 1881 by its first postmaster, John Sullivan, of Monticello, N.Y.

What stands in Monticello is mere of shell of its former glory days. More than 1,000 families once lived in Monticello Canyon, which contains both Monticello and Placita, during its peak. Today, there are fewer than 100 families. Some of the town's original buildings, including the old WPA school house and San Ignacio Catholic Church, still remain.

If you do not believe in ghosts, then what remains of the original school house might cause you to believe otherwise. All that remains is the exterior walls and foundations. Where students once sat and learned general arithmetic, trees and weeds now grow in their place. Rumors circulate about the cause of the building’s demise, but the most commonly believed is that the school had burned down after a student's experiment exploded in chemistry class.

Down on the main town square still stands the town’s original church, which was first built in 1869 and served as John Sullivan's home. The doors are usually left open for visitors to pop in and take a peak, and Mass is still celebrated. People say that on days when the Church is empty and quiet, you might be able to witness the "Monticello Light", a mysterious ball of light that once followed a local resident home.

Explore Monticello more at
New Mexico True

Or visit one of these local sources for more information about life in Monticello:
Tourism Website | County Website

Statistics (residential)

Total Listings: 1
Average Price: $725,000
Highest Price: $725,000
Lowest Price: $725,000

Roll over thumbnail to enlarge.

Listings in Monticello, NM

Search Results

1 Properties Found. Page 1 of 1

Own A Little Piece Of History With The Original...

$725,000 Active 6 Plaza De Monticello Rd, Monticello, NM
  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 4.7 Acres
  • 2,597 ft²


Own A Little Piece Of History With The Original Monticello Mercantile. The Cornerstone Commercial Property Of The Monticello Plaza, The Building Is A Beautifully Functional With Its Orignal Wood Floors, Bar, Post Office And Shelving. Just Across The Walk Wa...

MLS® #2002829
BHGRE Steinborn & Associates

All listing information was provided by Southern New Mexico Multiple Listing Service. The information being provided is for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Copyright © 2017 - Southern New Mexico MLS. All Rights Reserved.

Copyright © 2022 - Southern New Mexico MLS. All Rights Reserved.